Most Recommended Books

Track reading, wishlists & new-book alerts

Get
Skip to content
Share:

Wind River Reservation Books in Order

Part ofMargaret Coel Books in Order

See all the Wind River Reservation mysteries by Margaret Coel in order, with book summaries, series background, character notes, and suggestions on the best novels to start with.

Last updated: January 12, 2026

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases (at no extra cost to you).

Publication Order

Sort:

20 books

1

Winter's Child

by Margaret Coel

2016

Years after an Arapaho couple find an abandoned white infant on their doorstep, they are ready to adopt the girl they have raised as their own. When their lawyer is killed by a hit-and-run driver, Vicky Holden and Father John uncover a link between the child and one of Wind River's darkest secrets.

2

The Man Who Fell from the Sky

by Margaret Coel

2015

Robert Walking Bear dies in the Wind River mountains while hunting for Butch Cassidy's legendary cache with a family map. Rumors of greed and betrayal swirl, and when another relative dies, Vicky Holden and Father John pursue a killer willing to shed blood for outlaw treasure.

3

Night of the White Buffalo

by Margaret Coel

2014

After a mysterious man confesses murder in Father John's confessional and vanishes, rancher Dennis Carey is found shot dead on Blue Sky Highway. As a rare white buffalo calf draws pilgrims to Carey's ranch, Vicky and Father John investigate linked killings and disappearances on a reservation already on edge.

4

Killing Custer

by Margaret Coel

2013

During a parade reenacting the Battle of the Little Bighorn, a famous Custer impersonator is shot dead amid chaos between cavalry reenactors and Arapaho youth. Father John and Vicky must look past easy scapegoats to uncover a modern conspiracy rooted in clashing memories of the past.

5

Buffalo Bill's Dead Now

by Margaret Coel

2012

Regalia once worn by Arapaho Chief Black Heart in Buffalo Bill's Wild West show is finally returning home, until the shipment arrives empty. When the collector who arranged the donation is murdered, Vicky Holden and Father John trace a blood feud and artifact thefts stretching back more than a century.

6

The Spider's Web

by Margaret Coel

2010

After Vicky Holden agrees to represent a white woman accused of murdering her Arapaho fiancé, she finds herself at odds with much of the tribe, and even Father John. As tensions rise, the pair must untangle a web of lies surrounding a televangelist family and a psychopathic killer.

7

The Silent Spirit

by Margaret Coel

2009

Kiki Wallowingbull travels to Hollywood to learn what happened to his great-grandfather, an Arapaho extra who vanished while filming a silent western in 1923. When Kiki's body is found back on the reservation, Vicky Holden and Father John connect two deaths separated by nearly a century.

8

The Girl With Braided Hair

by Margaret Coel

2007

Human remains unearthed on Wind River are identified as Liz Plenty Horses, killed in 1973 after being accused of betraying the American Indian Movement. Vicky Holden and Father John peel back decades of silence, exposing old politics and new threats tied to her death.

9

The Drowning Man

by Margaret Coel

2006

When thieves chisel a sacred petroglyph called the Drowning Man from Red Cliff Canyon, Father John receives a ransom demand. As Vicky reopens an old case involving a similar theft and a suspicious death, the pair uncover a network profiting from stolen Native artifacts.

10

Eye of the Wolf

by Margaret Coel

2005

After three Shoshone men are found executed on the old Bates Battle site, an anonymous message warns, This is for the Indian priest. Father John and Vicky Holden must stop whoever is trying to reignite a war between Arapaho and Shoshone by exploiting a nineteenth-century massacre.

11

Wife of Moon

by Margaret Coel

2004

In this mystery linking two tragedies a century apart, Vicky Holden and Father John investigate the murder of a modern Arapaho woman alongside the long-ago killing of her ancestor. Clues from both eras reveal how unfinished history can still claim lives.

12

Killing Raven

by Margaret Coel

2003

The body of a white man is found on the Wind River Reservation just as a new tribal casino opens amid protests. Serving as the casino's counsel, Vicky uncovers evidence of fraud and danger, while Father John struggles to keep the peace as tensions escalate.

13

The Shadow Dancer

by Margaret Coel

2002

When Vicky Holden's ex-husband is shot soon after a bitter dinner, she becomes the prime suspect. At the same time, Father John probes a fringe religious group led by a man calling himself Orlando, and both trails converge in a deadly revival of the Shadow Dance.

14

The Thunder Keeper

by Margaret Coel

2001

A young Arapaho man apparently takes his own life at a sacred site high in the Wind River Mountains. When strange events follow, Vicky Holden and Father John suspect murder and dig into motives that reach from reservation politics to Denver's financial world.

15

The Spirit Woman

by Margaret Coel

2000

Drawn by the legend that Sacajawea is buried on Wind River, a historian friend of Vicky Holden vanishes while searching for the explorer's lost memoirs. Vicky and Father John retrace two women's journeys, past and present, to uncover who is silencing researchers.

16

The Story Teller

by Margaret Coel

1999

When a priceless Arapaho ledger book disappears from a Denver museum, Vicky Holden is hired to find it. After a student researching the book is murdered, she and Father John must recover the artifact and reveal why someone will kill to own the tribe's history.

17

The Lost Bird

by Margaret Coel

1999

Decades after a reservation clinic arranged questionable adoptions, an Arapaho woman's search for her birth family turns deadly. Father John and Vicky Holden investigate a long-ago baby-selling scheme, uncovering secrets powerful people would still kill to keep buried.

18

The Dream Stalker

by Margaret Coel

1997

When a nuclear waste storage project promises jobs and millions for the reservation, many Arapahos are eager to sign on. Vicky Holden fights the deal, and after a suspicious death and attempts on her life, she and Father John race to expose the scheme behind it.

19

The Ghost Walker

by Margaret Coel

1996

As winter closes in on the Wind River Reservation, Father John finds a body in a roadside ditch that vanishes before police arrive. When a young man disappears and a woman is killed, he and Vicky Holden must confront both a human killer and whispers of ghost walkers.

20

The Eagle Catcher

by Margaret Coel

1995

During the Ethete powwow on Wyoming's Wind River Reservation, Arapaho tribal chairman Harvey Castle is found murdered and his nephew is accused. Father John O'Malley and attorney Vicky Holden follow a trail through oil money and old injustices to clear the young man's name.

Series background & context

The Wind River Reservation series is Margaret Coel's long-running mystery sequence set among the Arapaho people of Wyoming. Across twenty books, it follows Jesuit priest Father John O'Malley and Arapaho attorney Vicky Holden as they investigate crimes that cut across tribal, church, and state lines.

The setting is as important as any character. Most stories move between the isolated St. Francis Mission church, the small towns edging the reservation, and the wide plains and canyons of Wind River country. Harsh winters, long drives, and big skies shape everything from how people work to how quickly help can arrive when trouble starts.

At the heart of the series is the partnership between Father John and Vicky. He is a history-loving priest and recovering alcoholic sent west to get his life back on track, and she is a sharp lawyer who left the reservation, then returned to fight for her people in court. They respect each other deeply, carry a quiet, complicated attraction, and often disagree about tactics, but they share the same stubborn sense of justice.

Each novel centers on a fresh case. In The Eagle Catcher, a tribal chairman's murder exposes corruption around oil leases and land. The Dream Stalker tackles a proposed nuclear waste dump that promises jobs at a terrible cost. The Spirit Woman and The Story Teller braid in Sacajawea lore and Plains ledger art, while The Drowning Man and Buffalo Bill's Dead Now turn on stolen sacred artifacts. Later books like Night of the White Buffalo, The Man Who Fell from the Sky and Winter's Child link present-day crimes to outlaw legends, ranch life, and an abandoned child whose past no one wants to face.

Always, the mysteries grow out of real pressures on the reservation rather than out of tidy puzzles alone.

Coel threads in ongoing themes: the legacy of massacres and broken treaties, the pull of traditional ceremonies and beliefs, the lure and danger of casinos, the impact of alcoholism and domestic violence, and the uneasy relationship between tribal law, federal law, and church authority. Through Father John and Vicky, readers see both insider and outsider perspectives on the same events, with small details of daily life making the world feel lived in, not exotic.

Although the books can be read out of order, starting near the beginning lets you watch the characters grow over time, from The Eagle Catcher through middle entries like Killing Raven or Eye of the Wolf and into the later novels. By the time the series closes with Winter's Child, the reservation, the mission, and the people around them feel like a familiar, if complicated, community.

Edited by

Richard Reis

Software engineer whose passion for tracking book recommendations from podcasts inspired the creation of MRB.

Anurag Ramdasan

Lead investor at 3one4 Capital whose startup expertise and love for books helped shaped MRB and its growth.

Comments

Did we miss something? Have feedback?

Help us improve this page by sharing your thoughts

We only use your email to notify you about replies.

All comments are moderated.

Discover and track your reading on the go

Track your reading, manage wishlists, and get notified when new books are added.

All 20 Wind River Reservation Books in Order (2026)